Philosophy Lexicon of Arguments

Author Item Excerpt Meta data

Books on Amazon
Gould I, 88ff
Richard Dawkins Thesis: Genes are the relevant units of selection.
Gould II
Dawkins Thesis: argues that the bodies are only temporary abodes of the genes, the real bearers of evolution.
Dawkins writes as a strict Darwinist.
II 172
Dawkins: Question: If the DNA is self-referring, why does it not create millions of copies of itself? That finally displace everything else? What is hindering it?
I 50
Gene/Dawkins: Genes live much longer than their bearers.
A gene can be understood as a unity that survives a multitude of successive individual bodies.
I 62
Def Gene/Dawkins: in the sense of the title this book it is more complicated than Cistron. There is no generally accepted definition for gene.
I would like to use the definition of G.C.Williams:
Def Gene: any piece of chromosome material that potentially survives so many generations that it can serve as a unit for selection. ((s) Circular?).
I 63
Inheritance/Copying Accuracy/Dawkins: "Longevity in the form of copies". VIII 64 The shorter a genetic unit, the longer it will probably live.
I 71
Dawkins Thesis: small genetic units can survive in identical form, individuals, groups and species cannot.
Gene/Dawkins: does not age! For it, the probability of dying at the age of one million years is not greater than at a hundred years.
I 73
"The cards themselves survive the shuffling."
Selection/Dawkins: If genes always mixed, the selection would be impossible in general.
I 74
Gene/Container/DawkinsVsGould: successful genes are good designers of survival machines. For example, creatures with long legs can flee better from predators.
What are the characteristics that immediately characterize a gene as good or bad?
I 75
Gene/Dawkins. Independent and free as they may be on their journey through the generations, they are very inhibited in the control of embryonic development.
There is no one gene that is responsible for developing a single body part.
I 86
Gene/Dawkins: there is a "gene for copying errors, (mutators)." It follows the selfish purpose of causing errors in other genes.
Similarly, a "gene for propagation" manipulates all others for its selfish purposes.

Body/Cell/Human/Dawkins: I prefer to imagine the body as a colony of genes, and the cell as a convenient work unit for the chemical industry of the genes.
I 112
Altruism/Gene/(Dawkins: a "gene for altruism" controls the development of the nervous system in such a way that it is very likely to behave selflessly.
For example, some bees pull their own larvae from the hive if they are infected.
I 115
The survival of the genes can also be promoted by seemingly altruistic behavior!
I 154
Gene/Dawkins: Thesis the gene may be able to help the copies of its own in other bodies.
I 155
E.g.: Albino gene in humans. We must, however, revoke our language somewhat: they do not actually "want" to survive or help other Albino genes.
But if it were to move its bodies purely by chance to behave towards other albinos in a more selfless way, the consequence would be that it would be more numerous in the gene pool.
For this, the gene must have two functions:
1) To produce light skin color ((s) Recognizability)
2) The tendency to altruism against other fair-skinned bodies.
Such a gene with two effects could be very successful.

Da I
R. Dawkins
Das egoistische Gen, Hamburg 1996

M. St. Dawkins
Die Entdeckung des tierischen Bewusstseins Hamburg 1993

> Counter arguments against Dawkins

> Suggest your own contribution | > Suggest a correction | > Export as BibTeX Datei
Ed. Martin Schulz, access date 2017-05-26